An All-Too Familiar Story:

Image
How Churches Drift Toward Death—and How to Turn Towards Life by Bart Denny I heard a story today that reminded me of too many I have heard before. It saddens me. It bothers me. The church I heard about seems to think they have it nailed, so I’m sure they won’t be seeking my consulting services—or anyone else’s. Not that a consultant’s report would make it beyond a file cabinet—stuffed away, never to be read. While I admit it may take many years—and that bad decisions will likely outlive most of the decision-makers—I remain less than optimistic about the church's future. There Are Patterns I’ll be the first to admit: I don’t know everything there is to know about church health, vitality, growth, and renewal. And I praise God that He still does what only He can do. I never want to box in the Holy Spirit. After all, we worship a God who parted the sea, turned water into wine, and reversed a crucifixion with a glorious resurrection. So no, I would never say that God can’t revive a chur...

Why Christians Should Oppose the Death Penalty (Even If the Bible Affirms It)

By Bart L. Denny, Ph.D., Th.M.

Let’s Be Honest: The Bible Doesn’t Shy Away from the Death Penalty

The Bible makes it plain: God established capital punishment as part of His justice. From Genesis 9:6 to Romans 13, Scripture consistently affirms the state’s right to wield the sword. Even Jesus, while showing mercy, never denied the legitimacy of that authority. So if Scripture supports the death penalty, why should modern Christians push back?

Here’s the Problem: Today’s Death Penalty Isn’t Biblical

Capital punishment, in God’s design, was supposed to be fair, swift, and just. The Mosaic Law didn’t hand out death sentences lightly. It required two or more eyewitnesses. It punished false testimony harshly. It didn’t discriminate. But our modern systems—particularly in the U.S.—are riddled with inconsistency, bias, and delay. They fail to meet the biblical standard.

What Justice Looks Like in God’s Eyes

  • High burden of proof (Deut. 19:15)
  • Equal treatment of rich and poor
  • Swift and decisive judgment—not years on death row
  • Real deterrence, not arbitrary executions

God’s justice isn’t just about punishment—it’s about truth, fairness, and upholding human dignity. When we support a system that falls short of that, we misrepresent His character.

The Numbers Don’t Lie

Did you know that only 0.4% of murderers in the U.S. are actually executed? Or that racial minorities, the mentally ill, and the poor are far more likely to receive the death penalty? Or that over 160 death row inmates have been exonerated (many posthumously) since 1973? That’s not justice. That’s a broken system.

So What Should Christians Do?

We should reject today’s practice of capital punishment—not because we reject the Bible’s moral clarity, but because we embrace it. Until we see a justice system that mirrors God’s righteousness, Christians should advocate for alternatives that protect society while upholding the dignity of life.

Final Thought

The death penalty isn’t inherently unbiblical. But the way it’s practiced today is. If we want to reflect God’s justice and mercy, we must call for systems that do the same. That’s not weakness—it’s faithfulness.


About the Author

Bart L. Denny, Ph.D., Th.M. is the lead pastor of Pathway — A Wesleyan Church in Saranac, Michigan. A retired U.S. Navy officer and former ship commander, Bart teaches in Grand Canyon University’s College of Theology and writes on topics like church revitalization, leadership, and biblical ethics. More of his work can be found at BartDenny.blogspot.com.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

But some doubted...

Leadership Development in Local Church Revitalization: A Review of the Literature and Suggestions for Further Research